When ERP Procurement Falls Short and What’s the Alternative?

ERP systems form the backbone of efficient operations for many organizations. They integrate finance, HR, sales, and supply chain management into one complex platform. Within this setup, an ERP procurement module helps companies make purchases and manage suppliers.

Numbers speak louder: According to Procurement Tactics’ top procurement trends in 2025, 83% of CPOs prioritize digitization. Companies want to move beyond traditional methods and adopt a more innovative approach. The question is, which systems offer the best path forward?

While ERP procurement modules have their perks, they often struggle to keep up with the increasing complexity and demands of modern procurement. This article will explore the pros and limitations of using an ERP procurement system and highlight key factors to help you determine whether it will suit your business needs. 

Keep reading to learn:

What Is ERP in Procurement?
Benefits of Using ERP for Procurement
Limitations of ERP Procurement Modules
The Evolving Needs of Modern Procurement
Why Specialized Procurement Platforms Are Worth the Investment
Which Is the Better Choice: An ERP Procurement Module or a Dedicated Procurement Platform?
Frequently Asked Questions

What Is ERP in Procurement?

ERP procurement module refers to the procurement features within an Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system. It helps manage purchasing, supplier relationships, and order processing while integrating procurement with finance, inventory, and other core business functions.

Typically, ERP for procurement offers the following functionality:

• Purchasing Management

ERP purchasing systems help companies create, approve, and track purchase orders to avoid delays and ensure timely deliveries.

• Supplier & Contract Management

Procurement ERP software centralizes supplier details (procurement contracts, payment terms, and performance history) for easier relationship management.

• Order Processing

ERP procurement systems digitize the entire order process, from purchase order creation to invoicing and payments.

• Inventory Management Integration

ERP systems integrate procurement with inventory, automatically updating stock levels and triggering reorder points when needed.

• Spend Management and Reporting

Procurement ERP software helps teams monitor expenses, prevent overspending, and boost process efficiency.

Benefits of Using ERP for Procurement

Companies using ERP in procurement particularly benefit when it comes to connected and integrated business planning. Let’s take a closer look at the other key advantages these solutions bring to the table:

Centralization of Business Processes

Instead of hopping between different tools, businesses can handle purchasing, supplier relationships, inventory, sales, HR, and finances all in one system. Centralization offered by ERP purchasing systems cuts down on manual tasks and keeps processes running smoothly and consistently.

Increased Collaboration Across Departments

ERP procurement modules foster enhanced collaboration across departments. By merging procurement data with other functions, ERP platforms keep everyone — finance, operations, and procurement teams — on the same page. Thus, with real-time insights, procurement ERP software cuts errors, streamlines teamwork, and drives faster, smarter decisions.

Enhanced Data Accuracy and Real-Time Insights

Fully integrated, the ERP purchasing system syncs modules used by different departments in real time, ensuring up-to-date, reliable data. Having one trusted source of information reduces the chances of errors or mix-ups. This streamlines the whole procurement process and boosts accountability.

Improved Compliance and Risk Management

ERP systems help ensure procurement activities comply with internal policies, regulatory requirements, and contractual obligations. These platforms reduce the risk of unauthorized purchases by automating purchase order management and approval workflows.

Additionally, procurement ERP software offers visibility into contract terms and supplier information. As a result, companies can proactively address delays or quality concerns with their preferred vendors.

Limitations of ERP Procurement Modules

Procurement ERP systems are good for getting the basics of purchasing in place, but they struggle to take those processes to the next level. As businesses grow or have more complex procurement needs, these limitations start to stand out. Let’s dive into some of the common challenges of ERP in procurement:

1. Lengthy Implementation and Steep Learning Curve

ERP implementation is rarely quick or seamless. For example, ERP integration with accounting and inventory can stretch beyond six months, requiring major IT and financial investments. Customization for procurement processes and approvals can extend timelines and increase costs even further.

Moreover, ERP systems have complex interfaces that require extensive user training.  This can mean taking procurement staff off their regular duties for weeks, impacting productivity. As a result, businesses often face operational disruptions (like supply chain disruptions or difficulty managing vendor relationships) before they see real benefits.

2. Complex User Interface and Usability Issues

In some cases, the rigid framework and clunky interface of ERP procurement modules frustrate users, even after training. If ERP disrupts established workflows, employees may sidestep it entirely and turn to older but faster and more familiar alternatives. This can undermine the entire purpose of implementing the ERP.

For new hires, the learning curve is even steeper. When an experienced user leaves, their replacement has to spend significant time learning the system rather than focusing on strategic procurement work. This ongoing dependency on specialized knowledge can create challenges and slow operations down when agility is needed most.

3. Lack of Flexibility and Customization

The standardized nature of ERP procurement systems can be a significant drawback for organizations with unique or evolving procurement needs. ERPs are designed for uniformity, which often clashes with the reality of diverse project requirements or geographically dispersed operations.

For example, businesses in sectors like healthcare or construction may struggle to manage complex supplier relationships, multi-tier sourcing, or local procurement rules. When the procurement system isn’t flexible enough, it can lead to workarounds that make things less efficient or even cause disruptions.

4. Insufficient Supplier Collaboration Tools

Effective supplier collaboration is critical for modern procurement, yet ERP procurement modules often fall short in this area. While they store supplier information and track basic interactions, they typically lack communication tools that facilitate real-time collaboration and issue resolution. 

For instance, suppliers may lack direct access to the system for checking orders, tracking payments, or collaborating on delivery schedules. Without these tools, procurement teams typically fall back on emails, phone calls, and spreadsheets, which can cause inefficiencies and lead to misunderstandings. On top of that, procurement ERP software often lacks the functionality to track and analyze supplier performance over time, which is key for strategic sourcing and building strong, long-lasting supplier relationships.

5. Gaps in Actionable Insights

ERP systems excel at collecting and storing vast amounts of data, but they often struggle to convert this data into real-time, actionable insights. Most ERP procurement modules provide only basic, static reports. 

They lack dynamic, customizable dashboards that effectively help procurement professionals monitor purchases and expenses across the entire organization. Without that flexibility, it’s harder to adjust strategies quickly and capitalize on cost-saving opportunities.

6. Lack of Advanced Automation Features

ERP procurement modules offer basic automation, such as purchase order creation and contract management. However, they rarely provide the advanced capabilities needed to fully streamline procurement. 

Many ERP systems lack AI-enhanced OCR (optical character recognition) for faster invoice processing. They also often miss custom reporting for tailored insights and intake management to streamline employee requests. Additionally, dynamic forms that adapt based on user input are rarely supported.

Without advanced tools, procurement processes become bottlenecked and slow. As a result, teams spend more time on manual work instead of focusing on strategic efforts like cost optimization.

The Evolving Needs of Modern Procurement

As industries grow and adapt to changing market conditions, procurement is becoming more complex and strategic. This is especially true for sectors like construction, logistics, wholesale retail, and healthcare. As a result, ERP procurement software becomes too rigid and limited to fully address the evolving needs and challenges of these industries. Let’s take a closer look at them.

Construction Industry

Construction thrives on complex projects and subcontractor networks. To stay competitive, procurement teams must build agile supply chains and solve these pressing issues:

Increased Project Complexity
Large construction projects span multiple locations, requiring precise coordination with suppliers and subcontractors. Procurement teams must track deliveries, manage orders, and control budgets under tight deadlines. Procurement mobile apps help on-site teams participate in the procurement processes without delays and disruptions. 

Fluctuating material costs
Raw material prices like steel, timber, and concrete are volatile. Construction companies can use blanket POs to manage these fluctuations without derailing the project schedule. These long term purchase agreements lock in the price and ensure a steady supply of materials reducing the risk of price increases impacting the project budget.

Compliance with regulations
Construction procurement is a juggling act with local building codes, safety standards, and environmental regulations. Making sure all supplies meet all the requirements can get tricky. That’s where the ability to send requests for proposals (RFPs) directly through procurement software comes in handy — it makes it easier to ensure suppliers meet regulations. Being able to request and store all those important supplier certificates right in the system keeps everything organized and easily accessible for the team.

Collaborative supplier relationships
Strong partnerships with suppliers and subcontractors are crucial for managing risks, ensuring timely deliveries, and avoiding cost overruns. Procurement software with punchout catalogs and a supplier portal helps strengthen these relationships by making transactions smoother and more efficient.

Punchout catalogs simplify purchasing by letting buyers browse real-time product listings, prices, and availability from suppliers right inside their procurement system. Additionally, a supplier portal centralizes communication as vendors can submit invoices, update catalogs, and track payments all in one place. This cuts down on endless email chains, boosts transparency, and fosters more collaborative partnerships.

Logistics Industry

For logistics, procurement platforms must streamline operations, mitigate supply chain risk, and optimize transportation. Key requirements are:

Vendor and Contract Management
Logistics companies need procurement platforms that make it easy to find the best transportation and service vendors through the RFP process and ensure competitive pricing and contract compliance. A procurement platform that sends notifications as contracts approach their expiration date is also highly useful. This helps track renewal dates and allows proactive renegotiations to avoid unexpected price hikes.

Spend Analytics and Optimization
Logistics companies need tools to analyze spending patterns across various suppliers and vendors. With real-time budget tracking, companies can watch their spending as it occurs. This means they can negotiate contracts more effectively and create smarter logistics strategies.

Supplier Collaboration & Integration
Seamless supplier integration is crucial for logistics companies. Procurement teams can achieve this by connecting key partners, including 3PLs, packaging suppliers, and fleet operators, directly through supplier portals within their procurement systems. This approach promotes clear communication, simplifies document tracking, and provides real-time updates, reducing delays caused by information gaps between parties.

Wholesale and Retail Industry

In wholesale and retail, procurement platforms help manage supplier relationships, inventory, and demand forecasting. Companies need to manage the following:

Procurement Process Across Multiple Locations
Many wholesale and retail businesses operate across multiple locations or branches, each with its own inventory, purchasing needs, and budget. That’s why they require multi-entity management within a single account in a procurement platform. 

This feature lets procurement teams handle purchases across different locations or branches and combine data into one central system. This provides visibility and control in all operations, simplifies procurement compliance, and enhances coordination.

Demand Forecasting and Inventory Management
Retailers have their hands full keeping the right amount of stock on hand, whether it’s hot-selling items, seasonal must-haves, or everyday essentials. To stay competitive and avoid running out of popular products, these businesses need real-time alerts when stock levels run low.

Businesses must track stock movements across different warehouses to minimize errors and maintain efficiency. Moreover, having a system that enables users to send warehouse requests ensures inventory gets replenished on time, keeping everything running like clockwork.

Multi-level Approval Workflows 
These are particularly essential for wholesale and retail businesses because of the complexity and scale of their procurement operations. In these industries, approvals often need to go through multiple levels of management, depending on factors like purchase value, supplier, or specific product categories.

Healthcare Industry

The procurement needs of the healthcare sector are driven by compliance, cost control, and the timely delivery of essential supplies. To meet these demands, procurement tools must provide the following functionalities:

Compliance with Regulations
Healthcare specialists need procurement platforms that adhere to standards like HIPAA and other privacy and security regulations. This ensures that data is secure and the entire procurement process aligns with healthcare-specific compliance needs, reducing the risk of regulatory violations.

Multi-Entity Management
Healthcare specialists, especially in large organizations, must easily manage and track orders across multiple facilities. This means they require a clear and unified process for requesting supplies, products, or services, all while maintaining cost-effectiveness.

Managing procurement at scale is easier when a system offers multi-entity management. It allows healthcare facilities to streamline the procurement process, group similar purchases, and predict demand across various sites. Ultimately, they can optimize spending while meeting the unique needs of every facility.

Inventory Optimization
Healthcare procurement involves keeping essential medical supplies and pharmaceuticals stocked. Real-time alerts for low inventory are key to addressing this. In an industry where timely access to supplies is critical, these alerts enable procurement teams to take immediate action, preventing shortages and ensuring uninterrupted patient care.

Why Specialized Procurement Platforms Are Worth the Investment

Though ERPs address fundamental business needs, they often lack the specialized features to optimize company-wide spend control, purchasing, and supplier relationship management. That’s why many companies choose to implement dedicated procurement software. Let’s take Precoro, a procurement centralization and automation platform, as an example and see the value of a specialized tool.

Smooth Implementation With Fast ROI

Procurement software is often faster and simpler to implement than a full ERP system. This is mainly due to its focus on one business area and its more user-friendly design. Unlike ERP purchasing systems, which require extensive configuration across multiple departments and processes, procurement software is often designed to easily integrate with existing systems. 

For example, Precoro’s setup typically takes 2-8 weeks, based on company size. Designed with the end users in mind, it features intuitive modules that streamline procurement workflows effectively — whether on desktop or via its convenient mobile app.

More Diverse Procurement Functionality

ERP systems cover many business processes, but when it comes to the nitty-gritty of procurement, specialized tools offer features to address the entire workflow. Procurement platforms are built with functionalities that can tackle the complexities of sourcing, supplier management, contracts, and budget control — areas that procurement ERP software usually covers in a more general sense.

For example, Precoro offers a Supplier Portal, punchout catalogs, automatic 3-way matching, AI-powered OCR, warehouse management, and advanced spend analytics. The goal of a system is to help businesses get full visibility and control over company-wide procurement and spending.

Multi-Entity Management

Precoro stands out because it can help manage multiple entities, which is especially useful for companies with many branches or subsidiaries. This feature helps businesses handle procurement easily from one platform and gives centralized control over expenses across different locations. 

Multi-entity management helps organizations keep procurement stable. They can set budget limits and track purchases across all offices in real time. Standardizing processes helps companies monitor spending to ensure all locations follow company policies and remain compliant.

High Level of Customization

Specialized procurement platforms bring a whole new level of customization that an ERP procurement module just can’t keep up with. Businesses can have the flexibility to really make the procure-to-pay cycle their own. For instance, with Precoro’s dynamic forms, teams can create flexible request forms, which are adjusted based on the information provided. Moreover, businesses can design custom approval workflows to match their needs, whether a quick two-step process or a detailed multi-level approval chain.

Custom fields for documents and budgets ensure that procurement teams can track exactly what matters most to them. Plus, with custom reports, stakeholders get insights that actually help decision-making instead of drowning in irrelevant data. This level of control makes procurement more efficient, transparent, and aligned with business goals.

Seamless Integration with Existing Systems

It’s possible to bridge the gap between procurement and other critical business functions without relying on the ERP procurement module. Precoro also breaks down procurement silos. Integrations with ERPs, accounting, and analytics tools ensure seamless data flow, fostering cross-functional collaboration beyond traditional ERP modules.

Anna Inbound Sales Representative at Precoro

We'll help ensure 100% compliance with your procurement policy across all departments and locations.

Book a Demo

Cost Savings

Procurement inefficiencies often result in significant financial losses, sometimes exceeding 10% of annual spending. Precoro helps businesses address this challenge by:

• Reducing procurement cycle times, leading to faster order processing and fewer delays.
• Negotiating better supplier terms by leveraging centralized procurement data and aggregating demand across multiple locations and departments for bulk purchasing.
• Enforcing budget control and providing real-time visibility into purchases and expenses to prevent overspending.

With Precoro, companies save up to 5% of their annual budgets. Increased cost control and better supplier relationships directly contribute to long-term savings and improved financial outcomes.

Which Is the Better Choice: An ERP Procurement Module or a Dedicated Procurement Platform?

When you’re deciding between an ERP procurement module or a dedicated procurement tool, it’s important to think about your business needs and future plans. ERP software gives you a lot of integrated functions, but specialized procurement tools are built to handle the details and complexities of procurement more efficiently. It all comes down to what will best support your team in the long run.

1. Assess Your Organization’s Size and Structure

When deciding between an ERP procurement system and a dedicated procurement tool, your organization’s size and structure is an important factor. Considering it will help determine which solution can best fit your procurement needs and align with your overall business strategy.

Small to Medium-Sized Businesses (SMBs)
An ERP procurement module may suffice if your company is relatively small or in the early stages of growth. Implementing an ERP system is a good way to consolidate various functions (finance, inventory, HR, sales, and more) within one platform and get basic procurement functionality. 

Research by the Institute for Public Procurement reveals a striking difference in ERP adoption between small and large companies. While 66.7% of small companies surveyed use ERP systems, only 16.2% of large companies do. That’s because ERP procurement modules work well for organizations with simple procurement needs that focus on purchasing and financial integration.

Large Enterprises or Complex Operations
A dedicated procurement tool works best for midsize companies and large enterprises. This is especially true if they have multiple business entities or operate in different regions or industries. Specialized procurement platforms are built for complex and evolving processes. They support strategic sourcing, intake management, supplier collaboration, and spend analytics. Additionally, they provide flexibility and advanced features for complex needs. These might go beyond what an ERP procurement module can handle.

2. Evaluate Procurement Process Complexity

To choose the right solution, it’s essential to assess the complexity of your procurement processes. Understanding whether your workflows are straightforward or involve multiple steps, approvals, and stakeholders will guide you toward a system that meets your specific needs.

Basic Procurement Needs
An ERP procurement module might be sufficient if your procurement needs are limited to basic purchase order management and supplier invoicing. ERP can handle standard transactions, ensuring that orders and invoices are processed seamlessly alongside your other business functions.

Advanced Procurement Needs
Businesses that need multi-level approval workflows for compliance or dynamic forms to adjust procurement requests by category or department will need more than just an ERP procurement module. Tracking supplier performance boosts negotiation power. Detailed spend analysis and customizable dashboards and reports provide insights for smart decision-making. A specialized procurement solution offers these features. It delivers the flexibility and depth needed for complex procurement tasks.

3. Consider Integration Options and Compatibility

When evaluating software providers, it’s important to consider how well their systems integrate with your existing tools and workflows. Ensuring compatibility will minimize disruptions and maximize the value of your investment.

All-In-One Solution
If your organization already uses an ERP system and seeks to keep all the business processes within a single platform, implementing an ERP procurement module can provide a centralized approach. With seamless data transfer between departments, an ERP system helps maintain consistency throughout the organization.

Dedicated Procurement Software with Integrations
If your organization has an existing ERP system but requires procurement capabilities beyond what the ERP procurement module offers, a dedicated procurement tool may be the better option. Standalone procurement platforms can be linked with ERPs and other business tools to handle complex tasks while keeping all processes and collaborators connected.

4. Take Into Account Budget Considerations

Before making a decision, it’s essential to weigh the costs involved in implementing and maintaining the system. Budget considerations will help ensure that the chosen solution aligns with your financial capabilities while still meeting your procurement needs.

Cost-Effective for Smaller Companies Already Using an ERP
ERP systems typically involve a higher upfront cost and a longer implementation time, especially when additional customization is required. However, for smaller organizations with budget constraints, adding a procurement module to an existing ERP system can be a more cost-effective choice.

Investment That Pays Off Quickly
Even if your company already has an ERP system but requires more advanced features than the ERP procurement module can offer, a dedicated procurement tool is a better long-term solution. While there’s an upfront cost to adopting a new platform, the return on investment (ROI) can be realized within just a few months.

For businesses that haven’t implemented an ERP system yet, investing in a dedicated procurement platform is a more agile solution compared to setting up a full ERP system. Standalone procurement tools provide the flexibility to scale and adapt as your company grows, allowing you to avoid the complexity and cost of a full ERP rollout.

5. Think About User Adoption and Experience

User adoption is crucial for the success of any procurement system. It’s important to consider how easily your team will be able to use the platform to ensure high engagement.

Steep Learning Curve and Unintuitive Interfaces
While ERPs cover a broad range of business functions, they can complicate procurement with their complex interfaces and settings. Procurement specialists end up spending more time trying to navigate the ERP purchasing system rather than completing tasks. These systems weren’t made specifically for procurement, so teams often need extra training to use them effectively.

User-Friendly Approach
Dedicated procurement tools are designed specifically for procurement professionals, so they’re easier to use and offer just the features they need. Plus, with focused training and dedicated support, a procurement team can often jump right in after one training session and get the most out of the system quickly. 

6. Examine Scalability and Future Growth

As your business grows, so will your procurement needs. It’s essential to choose a solution that can scale with your organization, allowing for future expansion without requiring a major overhaul.

Limited Scalability 
As your company grows, ERP systems can scale to accommodate increased procurement volume, new suppliers, and more complex workflows. However, ERP modules typically have limitations in customization and flexibility to meet highly specific procurement needs. If scalability is a major consideration for your business, note that a procurement ERP system can handle growth but may require extensive workarounds or integrations to fully support more complex procurement activities.

High Adaptability 
Dedicated procurement platforms are often built to scale with the organization. A specialized procurement platform like Precoro offers robust features that support future growth, such as multi-entity management, AI-powered document processing, unlimited custom fields, and company-wide spend visibility. Standalone tools are ideal for businesses looking to enhance their procurement function without relying on extensive IT resources for scalability.

7. Analyze Potential for Flexibility and Customization

When it comes to choosing the right procurement solution, flexibility and customization play a huge role. The ability to tailor the system to your specific needs ensures it continues to run smoothly as your requirements evolve.

A Less Specific Strategy
ERP procurement modules are generally less adaptable. Since ERPs are designed to support a wide range of business functions across the organization, customizing an ERP module to meet specific procurement needs often requires significant development work. Modifications can be time-consuming and costly, and changes may disrupt other parts of the system.

Room for Customization
A dedicated procurement tool offers greater flexibility and customization out of the box. For example, Precoro provides dynamic forms, multi-level approval workflows, custom fields for documents and budgets, custom reports, and personalized dashboards. 

Customization allows businesses to tailor procurement to their specific needs. This includes managing complex workflows, adapting to industry requirements, and responding to changing conditions.

Note! If you already use an ERP system but want the flexibility and in-depth functionality of a standalone procurement platform, you can have the best of both worlds! Consider implementing a procurement platform that integrates with your ERP solution. For example, Precoro’s integration with NetSuite provides a seamless two-way sync of financial documents, vendor information, locations, and more.

Frequently Asked Questions

Ready to boost your procurement?

Is ERP for Procurement the Answer to Your Needs?

The decision between an ERP procurement module and a dedicated procurement tool ultimately depends on your company’s size, complexity, and specific procurement needs. If you have simple procurement processes and prioritize integration with other business functions, procurement ERP software may be the best choice. 

If your organization is growing, needs more specialized procurement features, or deals with more complex challenges, investing in a dedicated procurement platform is the way to go. These tools offer flexibility and customization to streamline your processes, ensure company-wide compliance, and provide better insights into purchases and expenses. Plus, they’re much more scalable, so as your business grows and needs change, they can adapt without the limitations of rigid systems.

You can make a more informed decision by carefully assessing your organization’s current and future procurement needs. This evaluation will help you select the solution that not only addresses your immediate challenges but also aligns with your long-term business objectives and procurement goals.